Scroll down for updates.
From the Des Moines Register:
The Iowa Supreme Court this morning unanimously upheld gays’ right to marry.
“The Iowa statute limiting civil marriage to a union between a man and a woman violates the equal protection clause of the Iowa Constitution,” the justices said in a summary of their decision.
The court rules that gay marriage would be legal in three weeks, starting April 24.
You can read the full opinion here.
I’m stunned. I’ll blog more on this later, but right now I’m just shaking my head in disbelief.
Update: Decided to change the title of this post. Argon asks why am I stunned. I’m stunned because I grew up here, and have been back in Iowa for almost seven years after living out of the state for awhile. This decision doesn’t reflect Iowa values. Iowa is the third state to legalize gay “marriage” after Massachusetts and Connecticut. I never thought that we would “lead” the nation in this area. Yes, Iowa is trending blue, but that has been a pretty recent development. I guess I’m stunned because I had hoped and prayed this ruling wouldn’t come down this way, but I’m not surprised.
Polk County Attorney John Sarcone told the Associated Press that his office won’t ask for a rehearing, meaning the court’s decision should take effect after that three-week period.
"Our Supreme Court has decided it, and they make the decision as to what the law is and we follow Supreme Court decisions," Sarcone said. "This is not a personal thing, we have an obligation to the law to defend the recorder, and that’s what we do."
Advocates against same-sex marriage have said they would likely not appeal a ruling to the U.S. Supreme Court. They plan to ask lawmakers to pass a constitutional amendment and put the issue to voters.
That doesn’t surprise me because I don’t believe (I’ll have to check for sure) that the U.S. Supreme Court accepted appeals from Massachusetts or Connecticut, so there really isn’t a precedent SCOTUS intervention. A constitutional remedy seems to be the only solution, and apparently about 20 people went over to the Statehouse to discuss that with Iowa House Speaker Pat Murphy. The earliest that the citizens of Iowa can vote on such a measure is 2012.
Chuck Hurley, President of the Iowa Family Policy Center in response to this ruling and legislators’ earlier disbelief that DOMA would ever be overturned said:
Hurley said the Legislature should have passed such an amendment years ago. That would have headed off the lawsuit that led to Friday’s Supreme Court decision.
He said legislative leaders contended in the past that no constitutional amendment was needed, because the state already had a law banning gay marriage. “They said ‘The court’s not going to overturn the statute, you’re crazy,’ ” he recalled. “Well, now who’s crazy?”
Also the Des Moines Register interviewed different opponents and supporters of same sex “marriage,” and Senator Matt McCoy (D-Des Moines), the Iowa General Assembly’s only openly gay member was quoted saying, “I’m off the wall. I’m very pleased to be an Iowan.”
Well, Senator McCoy, I’m not. I’m ashamed to be an Iowan today.
My wife read an earlier version of this article when the opponents of same-sex marriage showed up to the Iowa Judicial Building, McCoy reportedly said, “Here comes the God Squad.” Interesting that they would scrub the latest edition. Is it the Register’s job to protect state senators from idiotic remarks? Methinks not.
Video: Raw footage of opponents of this ruling being interviewed by WHO-TV (Des Moines’ NBC affiliate):
- Robert Stacy McCain – power to the elites!
- 3 down, 47 to go – pray hard.
- Heritage blog – From Marriage to Mere Contract (HT: Pundette)
- Ed Whalen at NRO – The Iowa Supreme Court’s Attack on Marriage
- From the World Magazine Blog – American Gothic Redefined, even in light of this news – it made me laugh out loud.
And oh, Senator Matt McCoy (D-Des Moines) keeps running off at the mouth. Apparently he thinks it is a good idea for Iowa to become a Mecca for gay marriage. If his senate district is smart they’d give this loudmouth the boot. You can watch his video here or below.
HT: Iowa Independent
Also here are some names to remember when they come up for a retention vote (Iowa citizens get to vote to retain judges), obviously vote NO.
Chief Justice Marsha K. Ternus and Associate Justices Mark S. Cady (author of the opinion), Michael J. Streit, David Wiggins, Daryl Hecht, Brent R. Appel, and David L. Baker
Latest posts by Shane Vander Hart (see all)
- With Donald Trump as the Presumptive Nominee, I’m Still #NeverTrump - May 4, 2016
- Libertarians Pitch to Cruz Supporters, #NeverTrump Republicans - May 4, 2016
- Ted Cruz Suspends His Campaign - May 3, 2016