In Thursday’s Washington Post, culture critic Philip Kennicott had this to say about the "Obama as the Joker" poster that’s been popping up everywhere:

. . . The poster is ultimately a racially charged image. By using the "urban" makeup of the Heath Ledger Joker, instead of the urbane makeup of the Jack Nicholson character, the poster connects Obama to something many of his detractors fear but can’t openly discuss. He is black and he is identified with the inner city, a source of political instability in the 1960s and ’70s, and a lingering bogeyman in political consciousness despite falling crime rates.

Are you kidding me?

I realize that many critics like to analyze things to death. I’ve done it myself. But to twist the latest in a long line of politician-as-familiar-pop-culture-character depictions into an emblem of "racial fear," as the headline calls it, requires a level of overanalysis that borders on paranoia.

As it happens, I agree with Kennicott that the poster isn’t very effective. The word Socialism doesn’t fit all that well with a guy who just liked to go around blowing stuff up. But that doesn’t mean we need to go burrowing for some sort of super-secret hidden connection that throws the worst possible light not only on the anonymous artist, but on Obama opponents in general.

Kennicott only dug himself a deeper hole in a subsequent online chat, in which he affected a bland incomprehension of why so many people were bothered by his analysis.

Arlington, VA: Philip, I read your column and I have to say, take it easy. Maybe you need a little time off. It’s a poster, Philip, nothing more. Not that long ago we had a poster appear associated with Bush 43 showing an image of him with white powder under his nose and on his lip with the caption "Got Coke?" Whether anybody liked it or not, the republic somehow survived. This is not a big deal unless the media makes it one. It will pass. Take it easy.

Philip Kennicott: I agree I should take it easier, and I’m passing on this suggestion to my editors. I think you’re right about the general sturdiness of the republic in the face of withering political caricature. We have a long history of it, back to images of Andrew Jackson as emperor, and beyond. I tried to analyze the poster, and draw out some of the racial imagery, without declaring it a major blow to the body politic.

For a guy who likes to observe cultural artifacts under an electron microscope, Kennicott displayed an astonishing ability in this conversation to take things strictly at face value.

What’s really going on here, I suspect, is the same thing we saw going on when Nancy Pelosi tried to paint health-plan protesters as neo-Nazis, or when the media spread rumors of Palin rallies turning into breeding grounds for racial violence. It’s the same tired old academic cliché that holds that any opposition to liberals on ideological grounds must secretly be masking a fear of "The Other." The masses hate anyone whom they think is different from them in any way, the theory goes, and anything that conservatives say about political differences is just hiding that fundamental hatred. Thus Kennicott tells us, "The charge of socialism is secondary to the basic message that Obama can’t be trusted, not because he is a politician, but because he’s black."

The irony that people like Pelosi and Kennicott can’t or won’t see is that with their shallow, knee-jerk responses, they’re doing exactly what they accuse us conservatives of doing: creating a fear of The Other. Only this time, The Other is us.

— Gina Dalfonzo

Subscribe For Latest Updates

Sign up to receive stimulating conservative Christian commentary in your inbox.

Invalid email address
We promise not to spam you. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Thanks for subscribing!
  1. Mr. Nicholson played the joke twenty years ago. Shoot, I’d count myself a little old to go around slapping up posters mocking pols I don’t like, and I was too young to be allowed to see that movie when it came out…. A scary guy in a very recent movie who burned a huge pile of money and took great glee in forcing horrible hard choices on folks is a heck of a lot more likely a connection than a not-very-scary-at-all guy who seemed to fall into a vat of easter egg dye and then gassed everyone during a parade…

    That said, I kinda like the “Why So Socialist?” version, made me lol, and I’m sick of the “why so serious” puns…..
    .-= Foxfier´s last blog ..OUCH! =-.

  2. Call me crazy … there is no up-side to the Joker thing. It’s a stupid campaign that won’t win anyone over. It plays well with people who already hate Obama, but won’t persuade supporters that there’s a problem. Rather, it will galvanize supporters against the self-evidently-flawed Obama-as-psychopath joke.

    On the other hand, it should be derided for its inappropriateness and juvenile nature. To try to tie it to racism is more than a little silly.

    This, unfortunately, is what a lot of political discussion. Lots of yelling and inflammatory rhetoric, no sense.
    .-= Wickle´s last blog ..Two Blog Tours =-.

Comments are closed.

You May Also Like

Why Do We Need a Right-to-Try Bill in America?

Dr. Jane Orient: Nowhere does the U.S. Constitution give the federal government the authority to regulate the practice of medicine. And it is a very good thing that federal intervention and standards didn’t begin in 1789.

Grassley, Ernst Push for Bill Northey’s Confirmation to USDA

U.S. Senators Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) and Joni Ernst (R-Iowa) spoke in favor of Bill Northey whose confirmation vote for Under Secretary of Agriculture for Farm and Foreign Agricultural Services at the U.S. Department of Agriculture is being blocked by U.S. Senator Ted Cruz (R-Texas).

Grading Obama, Part One

In the first installment of a series grading President Barack Obama’s time in office Adam Graham looks at Obama’s economic and social agendas.

What Does Trump Gain By Attacking His Own Justice Department on Twitter?

Shane Vander Hart: President Donald Trump is the first President to attack his own administration on Twitter and I’m not sure what he gains by it.