Following up on yesterday’s death match and Craig Robinson looked no worse for wear as I had lunch with him today.  I also saw Steve Deace today (he was in the same restaurant awkward – just kidding)  and he also appeared to unscathed.  It was a good debate though Craig was just slightly outnumbered.  I personally think that Craig had the sounder argument and he brought up a couple of points.

  • What if President Obama since he decided he didn’t like the Supreme Court’s ruling on the corporate contributions aspect of the McCain-Feingold Act and declared a stay order that ruling to be disregarded.  Many would have a conniption fit and rightfully so.  Or what if the day comes during the Obama Presidency when Roe v. Wade was overturned.  We really don’t want to give additional authority to the Chief Executive.
  • The argument is largely based on what the phrase “chief magistrate” means and the supporters of an executive order to place a stay on the Iowa Supreme Court’s ruling on the Defense of Marriage Act read too much into that phrase.

Both Craig and I today agreed that if the Iowa Constitution clearly gave the Governor the authority of an executive order to place a check on the Judicial Branch’s power then we both would say go for it.  But the Constitution gives only two remedies for this problem either a constitutional amendment process that first goes through the Legislature or a Constitutional Convention.  The only check that a Governor has over the Judicial Branch is in the appointment process.

Deace shares his thoughts about the debate today, and Robinson blogged about it here.  Listen to the debate above and let me know what you think.

Comments are closed.

Get CT In Your Inbox!

Don't miss a single update.

You May Also Like

Iowa Republicans Will Have 19 Contested Primaries for Iowa House and Senate

The Iowa Secretary of State released the final uncertified list of candidates that will appear on the June 5th primary ballot. Iowa Republicans will have 19 contested primaries with five incumbents receiving a challenge.

Governor Branstad Thanks Matt Strawn for His Service to the Republican Party of Iowa

Iowa Governor Terry Branstad thanks Matt Strawn for his service as Iowa GOP Chairman after news of Strawn’s resignation.

Iowa Legislative Leaders: Sluggish Revenue Growth Requires Reform

The decline in the revenue estimate triggered concerns about the overall state budget from Iowa Legislative leaders heading into a new session.

First Iowa U.S. Senate GOP Primary Debate Wrap-Up

Recap and full video of the AFP/NRO Iowa U.S. Senate GOP Primary debate. Caffeinated Thoughts also wants to hear from you who do you think won?