We’ve been discussing the constitution quite a bit lately, in particular the 10th Amendment as several Governors and Gubernatorial candidates have said they would invoke it if ObamaCare passes.  In the post related to the 10th Amendment a couple of readers noted that we wouldn’t be in this mess if we didn’t have the 17th Amendment, and they advocated for its repeal.  It says, in case you are not familiar:

The Senate of the United States shall be comprised of two Senators from each State, elected by the people thereof, for six years; and each Senator shall have one vote.  The electors in each State shall have the qualifications requisite for electors of the most numerous branch of the State legislatures. 

When vacancies happen in the representation of any State in the Senate, the executive authority of such State shall issue writs of election to fill such vacancies: Provided, The the legislature of any State may empower the executive thereof to make temporary appointments until the people fill the vacancies by election as the legislature may direct.

This amendment shall not be so construed as to affect the election or term of any Senator chosen before it becomes valid as part of the Constitution.

Before 1913 when this amendment was ratified, “we the people” didn’t elect Senators.  If you look at Article I, Section 3 of the U.S. Constitution, the first sentence reads, “The Senate of the United States shall be composed of two Senators from each State, [chosen by the Legislature thereof,] for six Years; and each Senator shall have one Vote.”

Our state legislatures chose who would represent the State in the United States Senate.  The House of Representatives was the House of the people, the Senate was the House of the States.  There were some advantages to this system.

  • Theoretically, you wouldn’t have lifetime Senators.  If the make-up in the Legislature changed your Senator likely changed.
  • They represented the interests of the State and were directly accountable to the State Legislatures (who in turn “we the people” can provide greater accountability and have greater access to).  For instance, it is relatively easy in most states (I know it is in my case) to stop by the Capitol building and meet with my state representative and state senator.  If I have an issue with what is being done in Washington, I can let them know.  They in turn would have greater influence on a U.S. Senator.  Today they virtually none.
  • It is unlikely that unfunded mandates would get passed down to the States, or we would see the Federal government encroach on the role of the Several States if they were accountable and selected by State Legislatures.
  • With this system you see true federalism, dual federalism taking place with a greater balance between the Federal government and the States (which was the intent of the Founders I believe).

Potential problems with a repeal of the 17th Amendment, as it was ratified for a reason.

  • Partisanship could hamper an appointment by the State Legislature (that was seen in the late 19th century).
  • The appointment process could be iffy, how would the Legislatures choose?  Would names be submitted by application?  Would people campaign among the Legislators?
  • With the current makeup of the Iowa Legislature for instance I would not be thrilled with them appointing a new Senator since Senator Chuck Grassley’s term is about up.

In addressing some of these issues, each State could address how the problems were handled.  Another beauty of a federal system.  What works in one particular state may not work in another.  Some states may still want a direct vote (some did prior to the 17th Amendment) and others may not.

Anyway, it was an argument that I’ve not really considered before and it seems to have some merit in my mind.  What do you think?

7 comments
  1. I’ve discussed this topic, for years, with ‘normal’ people (i.e. non-political junkies) and I’ve come to only one conclusion: there is no way, on this God’s earth, this will ever happen. (Most of them think I’m flat-out insane and, those that do listen…think I’m flat-out insane)–you will pry the right to vote for senators from the cold, dead, hands of the average individual, even if they don’t vote!

    (Of course, getting the 17th passed in the first place was a masterstroke of socialist-leaning pols of the early 20th, playing the ‘corruption’ card to get it through the front door.(And clearly that’s worked out phenomenally because there’s no more special interest corruption at all…what? Oh…never mind.))

      1. @Shane Vander Hart, I’m still stunned that Americans of the day managed to convince themselves that they could one-up the Founders on the creation of a better government. (Then again, I look at the Left today…)

  2. This is one of the things I’ve been thinking about lately. Until I get information that would make me change my mind, I’m all for repealing the 17th.

  3. I have no idea why people think this would “fix” anything. The desire to do this seems to be based in distrust of the federal government…….as if state governments are doing a bang-up job these days? The base group promoting this is the conspiracy theorist crowd followed then by the Campaign for Liberty, and the (slightly perhaps) larger so-called “liberty movement”. You’re talking about spending your energies lobbying for a nearby fire hydrant while your house is burning. It’s a total waste of energy, in other words. This is what happens when panicked people aren’t thinking clearly. The house is burning? Quick! Let’s lobby for a fire hydrant! If you’ve got no fire hydrant, you go with what’s reasonable and available to you right now whether it’s a sack of flour, a hose, or calling 911. If you can’t vote smart in a federal election, you can’t vote smart in a state election, either. It doesn’t “fix” anything.
    .-= Lisa Graas´s last blog ..About That Civil War Thing… =-.

Comments are closed.

Get CT In Your Inbox!

Don't miss a single update.

You May Also Like

President Obama’s Credibility Goes Down The Tube

The Obama administration is “hitting the panic” button on what could be…

Tea Party Diversity

Great video put together by the Dallas Tea Party that dismisses the…

Sarah Palin with Greta

Governor Sarah Palin had Greta Van Susteren with her in North Carolina…

Steve King-Crafted Obamacare Repeal (H.R. 2) to Be Debated Today, Vote Expected Tomorrow

Language crafted by Congressman Steve King (R-IA) for the repeal of Obamacare…