Four Iowa voters filed suit yesterday in federal court to stop the dominating influence of attorneys over the system for selecting state judges in Iowa, arguing that this influence denies ordinary Iowa voters an equal voice in selecting justices for the Iowa Supreme Court.

Three Iowa Supreme Court justices lost their retention elections this November. Under Iowa law, nominations for their replacements are made by the fifteen member State Judicial Nominating Commission. Only candidates nominated by the Commission may be appointed by the Governor. Since all nominees allowed to move forward by the Commission may be opposed to the Governor, the Commission, and not the people, has complete control over who becomes a judge in Iowa. Seven of Commission members are selected in elections in which only attorneys can vote. The current system thus guarantees lawyers a far greater say than ordinary citizens in Iowa in selecting judges who have great power and control over the lives of regular citizens.

The suit asks the court to stop the elected members of the Commission from participating in the nomination process and to stop any future election restricted to attorneys. The Commission can go forward and make its nominations without attorney member participation. According to attorney James Bopp, Jr., lead counsel for the plaintiffs, the Iowa system “gives attorneys a stranglehold on the judiciary. Lawyers in Iowa have enormous influence over who the state judges are, while the ordinary voter is denied the right to an equal voice.”

The case is Carlson, et al. v. Cady, et al. The complaint and memorandum supporting the motion for a temporary restraining order are available in PDF format online at the James Madison Center’s website, www.jamesmadisoncenter.org.

2 comments
  1. I would hope that lawyers would be the ones picking judges, they have experience in the judical system and would know what to look for. There’s a reason we let experts have more authority in their field of interest. It’s the same reason we don’t have people vote for safety regulations of airplanes — leave it to the experts.

Comments are closed.

Get CT In Your Inbox!

Don't miss a single update.

You May Also Like

Five Items of Interest: Fed’s Takeover of Education, Kim Pearson & Iowa HD 30, Hawkeyes, Chromebooks, and Iran

It’s been awhile, but I did want to bring back the five…

Brad Zaun Woos Liberty Voters in Iowa’s 3rd Congressional District Race

“I took off my jacket because I’m not packing tonight,” joked Brad…

Liveblog: 2018 Iowa GOP State Convention

I am live-blogging today’s Iowa GOP State Convention today at the Jacobsen Center on the Iowa State Fairgrounds. Follow along!

Vote No on the Retention of Iowa Supreme Court Justices

By Dale Mastarone In the 10-21-10 Osceola Sentinel-Tribune I took interest in…