The  Iowa Federation of Labor’s President, Ken Sager, spoke against HJR 6 (which passed in the Iowa House today) at the public hearing on the resolution (listen below) in the Iowa House chamber last night.  He “took liberty” with German Lutheran Pastor Martin Niemoller’s famous statement, “First they came.”

Sagar “paraphrased” the pastor who endured Nazi persecution when he said:

When they came for the minorities I did not speak out because I was not a minority.

When they locked up the immigrants, I said nothing as I wasn’t an immigrant.

When they came for the gays I did not speak out because I was a gay.

While there are several variations to Niemoller’s statement the most often quoted is this:

First they came for the communists,
and I didn’t speak out because I wasn’t a communist.
Then they came for the trade unionists,
and I didn’t speak out because I wasn’t a trade unionist.
Then they came for the Jews,
and I didn’t speak out because I wasn’t a Jew.
Then they came for me
and there was no one left to speak out for me.

Some versions also mention Catholics.  I can understand speaking passionately about this issue.  It is an incredibly important discussion for Iowans to have.  I do have a huge problem with Mr. Sagar’s reference to this statement.  Linking persecution at the hands of Nazis in concentration camps to merely wanting to vote on the definition of marriage is vilifying the opposition.  It is inappropriate, and I’ve been consistent with this position when it was directed at those with whom I disagree.  Also what immigrants are getting “locked up”?  Illegal immigrants?  Who is coming for the gays?

Nobody.  Nobody.  Those of us who don’t believe that the Iowa Supreme Court had the authority to change the definition of marriage want a public discussion and debate.   We want to be allowed to decide this matter for ourselves (and we understand we could lose the vote).  We don’t want to see homosexuals mistreated.  Comparing those who are in favor of this bill to Nazis is out of line.   This rhetoric contributes nothing to a civil debate.

You May Also Like

Iowa Department of Public Health Reports 73 Additional COVID-19 Cases, One Death

The Iowa Department of Public Health reports that the state now has 497 cases of COVID-19 in 58 counties and seven COVID-19 related deaths.

Pate Plan Promotes and Strengthens Iowa Elections

Iowa Secretary of State candidate Paul D. Pate has released his plan to encourage voter participation while strengthening the integrity of Iowa’s elections.

When An Activist Becomes A Legislator

Shane Vander Hart: It is irresponsible of State Sen. Claire Celsi to encourage a boycott of an Iowa-based business because of the owners’ private donations.

Promises Kept This Legislative Session

State Representative Steven Holt (R-Denison): Promises were kept as we worked to advance freedom and opportunity for Iowans, based on our founding values.