imageThe Boston Herald, not a conservative or limited government bastion by any stretch of the imagination, railed against the common core state standards for science.  These are the same standards that Jason Glass and the Iowa Department of Education want to align the Iowa Core Curriculum to.  The Herald’s Editorial Board writes:

An influential body has proposed new science curriculum standards (“frameworks” in education jargon). The state board plans to align the Massachusetts standards with whatever national ones emerge. Both the board and the national organizations sponsoring the “Common Core” project should reject this bewildering effort from the National Academy of Sciences.

We were alerted to this by Ze’ev Wurman, a software expert who helped develop California’s standards and who commented critically on the new Massachusetts standards. In his blog comment on the Academy’s proposal he said: “The framework does not expect students to use any kind of analytical mathematics while studying science.”

The document only expects students by grade 12 to be competent in recognizing this and expressing that, and in using “simple mathematical expressions’” to see if something “makes sense,” Wurman wrote.

Wurman could find only one equation in all 280 pages of the proposal. A careful reading of the 29 pages of the physical sciences section, where equations would be most important, found none at all.

This is baffling. Mathematics, to which the authors devoted much praise, is the language of science. Wurman’s conclusion, which we share: The document “simply teaches our students science appreciation.”

So the science standards stink as well, no surprise there.  I’m sure the Iowa Department of Education will march forward in lockstep regardless.

You May Also Like

State of Iowa Announces Three Additional Test Iowa Sites

The state of Iowa announced Test Iowa will open three new clinic sites for COVID-19 in communities across the state beginning Monday, June 22, 2020.

New Reynolds TV Ad Focuses on Her Role as a Grandmother

Iowa Governor Kim Reynolds’ campaign released an ad that focuses on how being a grandmother of 10 has prepared her in her role as Governor.

Iowa Secretary of State-Elect Matt Shultz Announces Transition Team

Council Bluffs, Iowa – November 10, 2010 – Secretary of State elect,…

Large Class Sizes and Public Education Funding in Iowa

With Des Moine Public Schools seeing classes that have over 40 students is the state of Iowa’s level of funding for K-12 education really the problem?