property-tax-dollarThe flip side of the business property tax discussion is the homeowner or homestead property tax status. Managing the balance between the two is critical to the overall success of our citizens. If business taxes are too high, they will not open new facilities and hire new workers. If residential taxes are too high, families will not be able to buy homes. Before deciding to change the tax structure at all, one should compare the business and homeowner taxes and effective tax rates with others nationally. The Minnesota Taxpayers Association’s (MTA) “50-State Property Tax Comparison Study” provides a useful overview.

The basic analysis in the MTA study compares the tax rate for a $1 million commercial property to the median value of a “homestead” property for each state. A ratio is generated, dividing the $1 million by the median home value. This shows whether or not a homeowner’s taxes are subsidized by commercial taxes. It is also possible that homeowner taxes are subsidizing commercial taxes. A one-to-one ratio reflects no subsidy on either side. In FY 2010, Iowa urban commercial taxes were subsidizing homeowners by a 2.249 to 1 ratio on a median home value of $156,200 in Des Moines. This ranks 12th in the nation. The national average is a ratio of 1.641 to 1, which has declined over the last two years.

Additionally, when looking at the apartment property tax classification, Iowa apartment owners also subsidize Iowa homeowners by 2.249 to 1. This is fifth highest in the nation, after New York City, Columbia, Indianapolis (Indiana), and Providence (Rhode Island).

According to the MTA, in the 13 states where there is little or no homeowner subsidy, overall property taxes have increased by less between 1998 and 2008 than in other states. This would appear to reflect a stable, in-balance tax system, where governments are satisfied with the money they receive and both business and residential property owners appear to be satisfied with the amount they are taxed. In states where tax rates are out of balance, either one side or the other is advocating for reform.

Where the proper balance is between business and residential property tax rates, and between Iowa and other states, is yet to be decided. Iowans are interested in seeing that the tax structure is logical, easy to understand, and crafted in a thoughtful manner which considers the interests and needs of all taxpayers – whether business or individual. We are interested in ensuring that the taxes collected are used in appropriate and efficient ways. In general, neither homeowners or business owners are interested in paying higher taxes, except for individuals such as Warren Buffet – who thankfully neither resides in Iowa nor is an elected official here.

Get CT In Your Inbox!

Don't miss a single update.

You May Also Like

Senator Chuck Grassley’s First Campaign TV Ads

DES MOINES – U.S. Sen. Chuck Grassley’s re-election campaign is airing its…

Ernst Raises Almost $1.7 Million in First Quarter of 2019

U.S. Sen. Joni Ernst announced raising almost $1.7 million in the first quarter of 2019 and now has over $2.8 million on hand for her 2020 re-election bid.

Iowans Want Tax Cuts Sooner Rather Than Later

Iowans for Tax Relief President Chris Ingstad called for income tax cuts, spending restraint, and occupational licensing and regulatory reform at Gov. Kim Reynolds’ public budget hearing.

Team Joni Unveils New Virtual Campaign Headquarters

Joni for Iowa’s new virtual campaign headquarters, JoniHQ, will serve as an online home base for Iowans working to re-elect U.S. Senator Joni Ernst.