Confederate Flag flown in 2008 by a Confederate War Memorial on the South Carolina Statehouse grounds.Photo credit: Jason Lander (CC-By-2.0)
Confederate Flag flown in 2008 by a Confederate War Memorial on the South Carolina Statehouse grounds.
Photo credit: Jason Lander (CC-By-2.0)

I am a Northerner. I grew up in a northern state.  I have at least one ancestor who fought for the North in the Civil War.  I am a member of a Northern Civil War reenacting unit and am a member of the Sons of Union Veterans of the Civil War.  I do not agree with the South’s reasons for secession or its practices of slavery, and consider men like Jefferson Davis and JEB Stuart to be some of the great villains of American history.

As a Civil War reenactor I have read thousands of pages on the subject from a variety of sources from Shelby Foote and Bruce Caton to many of the primary sources.  The Southern leaders wanted to establish a separate country where slavery was legal and where a racial caste system was permanent with blacks being property of the white dominant class.  They started the Civil War, but not every Southerner was for slavery or secession. In some areas of the South, the majority did not favor secession and in some of those areas, the Southern leaders had to resort to military force and intimidation to keep them in line.  It is evident from the writings of individual Southerners that they weren’t fighting for slavery, either.  They were fighting for home, hearth, and freedom from what they saw as a government in Washington that was trying to encroach upon their freedom.

As a Civil War reenactor I have a number of friends who serve in Confederate reenacting units and relatives from the South.  They are proud of their Southern heritage.  They know slavery was wrong.  They are not proud of being Southern because of slavery, but because being Southern means having a free spirit and being independent minded.   It’s the rebel spirit and the rebel yell. They don’t see the Confederate Battle flag in its various forms as an emblem of slavery, but an emblem of freedom, and whether or not someone else likes it, those beliefs need to be respected.  If they want to fly the Confederate Battle flag in its various forms it is their right and they should just be left alone.

1 comment
  1. Thank you. I had ancestors on both sides of the war. After doing some research, it is hard to understand why the southerners fought at all. It was a lost cause. The North did a slave census in 1850 and in 1860 and knew exactly where every slave owner and slave was in the South and everything else the Northern Army needed to know about overpowering the Southerners. They had maps. The 1860 census is on the net and can be googled for more information. Wikipedia has some good info. My Northern ancestor never recovered mentally from the war and was in a military hospital on and off during his life. His (my) family suffered for generations. His ancestors had fought in the Revolutionary War and the war of 1812 and the Black Hawk War, even serving under Lincoln in Illinois…My family in Sangamon County, Illinois related to Lincoln by marriage (his step-mother was an aunt) did not think much of Lincoln after the war.

Comments are closed.

Get CT In Your Inbox!

Don't miss a single update.

You May Also Like

Gallup: A Majority of Americans Want Abortions Restricted

Gallup’s new biennial poll on abortion shows that 54 percent of Americans want abortion illegal in all but a few circumstances.

Duck Dynasty, Mike Huckabee, Phil Robertson, Haley Barbour, David VanDrunen

In late December 2010, Mike Huckabee, was still considering a run at…

Spiritual Whores

I’ve been reading Hosea in an Accountabilibuddy group and it has struck…

The Deficit: A Behavioral Economic Analysis

Regular readers will by this time be familiar with Behavioral Economics, the…