coronavirus news on screen
Photo by Markus Spiske on Pexels.com

Frequently over the last six months Iā€™ve seen people write the following pronouncement about COVID-19: ā€œItā€™s not the flu!ā€

They are right, of course.

COVID-19 can be a vicious disease in a number of ways in which influenza is not. For example, COVID-19 can cause blood clotting issues in severe cases. The clotting can manifest itself in deep vein thrombosis or in tiny clots that block small blood vessels in the lungs, contributing to respiratory failure. The virus also can permanently damage the heart muscle, and cause long term damage to other organs such as the kidneys and the brain. Again, it can be a vicious disease in ways that the flu isnā€™t.

But when people say ā€œItā€™s not the flu!ā€ they are really missing the point that I think is being made when other people compare COVID-19 to the flu. People arenā€™t comparing the nature of the two diseases in any medical or scientific way. Whether they explicitly say it or not, what they are driving at is risk assessment. Itā€™s something we all do in virtually every area of life, usually without much thought.

Influenza is something of a gold standard in terms of risk assessment with respect to infectious disease. The reasons for that are obvious: We are quite familiar with influenza. We know its pandemic history and its mortality history. When people make comparisons between COVID-19 and the flu, a lot of them arenā€™t seeing a considerable difference (so far, at least) between the two in that regard. But they see a big difference in our response to COVID-19, knowing that our response to the flu hasnā€™t involved business closings, quarantines, and the like for the past century– not even in the case of an outbreak such as the one in 1968 which took the lives of 100,000 Americans.

Of course itā€™s not the flu. But relative to risk assessment in connection with public policy, perhaps it should be considered more like it.

This is Brian Myers with your Caffeinated Thought of the Week.

You May Also Like

Court Rules the University of Iowa Engaged in Viewpoint Discrimination

U.S. District Court Judge Stephanie Rose found that the University of Iowa engaged in viewpoint discrimination and violated Business Leaders in Christ’s First Amendment rights.

Friday Five Items of Good News (Vol. 7)

Every Friday, Shane Vander Hart shares five items of good news or inspiring stories from the week to end the work week on a positive note.

Why Ireland Should Vote No To The Fiscal Compact

Those of you who have followed the developing Eurozone crisis have certainly…

Habemus Papam: Papal Conclave Elects Argentine Cardinal Pope

The Papal Conclave elected Jorge Mario Bergoglio, Archbishop of Buenos Aires, Pope on the 5th round of ballots. He has taken the name Pope Francis I.