I was pretty shocked when I learned that Senator Sam Brownback (R-Kansas) decided to back Governor Kathleen Sebelius’ (D-Kansas) appointment as U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services.
Primebuzz/Kansas City Star reports:
After a day of uncertainty, Kansas Sen. Sam Brownback said Tuesday he would vote to confirm Gov. Kathleen Sebelius for secretary of Health and Human Services.
“The President won the election and has nominated a Kansan to the cabinet,” Brownback said in a statement. “Despite our profound policy differences, I will support my fellow Kansan.”
This seems unfathomable to do such a thing since this post has much sway on Right-to-Life issues, and she will give a boost to the abortion and stem cell industries in this role. He is already being accused of “throwing the unborn under the bus.” Apparently he has a political explanation for his decision according to Dan Gilgoff of U.S. News & World Report:
But two sources tell me that Brownback’s people have been making the case to antiabortion groups—especially those in Kansas—that there’s a strong political rationale for installing the Kansas governor in Washington. The move gets her out of Kansas, Brownback’s argument goes, heading off her expected run for the Senate in 2010. Which means the Sunflower State Senate seat that Brownback’s vacating for a gubernatorial run is likely to stay in Republican hands, since the Kansas Democratic Party doesn’t have another candidate who is half as popular as Sebelius. And that’s good for the antiabortion cause, according to the reasoning.
I suspected that there was likely a pragmatic, political reason for his decision. But does it really matter? Does this really advance the pro-life cause? I’m concerned about the damage that could be done by this appointment. I am surprised because Senator Brownback has been nothing but solid on pro-life issues that have come up in the Senate.
Update: Kevin Tracy’s defense of Senator Brownback.
2nd Update: Thanks Pundit & Pundette and Lisa Graas for the linkage.
3rd Update: Jill Stanek reported on some fireworks between Senator Brownback and Family Research Council’s Tom McClusky at the Senate Values Action Team Meetings
Shane Vander Hart
Latest posts by Shane Vander Hart (see all)
- A Mob Is A Mob Is A Mob - October 20, 2018
- (Video) Mike Pence Stumps for David Young - October 19, 2018
- The Most Depressing Ad I’ve Seen - October 19, 2018
I'm pretty well resigned that she would get confirmed with or without Brownback's support.
I'm ok with deep-sixing incumbents to a point – there are some good incumbents who have truly served their constituents well and I'd hate to think who might replace them. But I know we won't get term-limits passed any other way.
I can't deep-six my ideology though. There are just some people I could never vote for.
I think that is part of the rationale of not appointing her – she wouldn't run unless she quit the HHS post before Obama's first term is done.
Voting ideology will always result in the impossibility of term limits.
I have decided that the system needs to be fixed and the only way to do it is to vote against the incumbent every time.
Yet I understand why you don't young Skywalker.. the Emperor has trained you well.. use the force Luke 🙂
Rationale.. or rationalization.. is probably the right word. Sam is becoming a big disappointment.. I have voted for him and Kansas Senator Roberts because of their pro-life rhetoric.
I appreciate your heart for these issues, Shane…and picking our battles is important.. Some of our brothers and sisters approaches, (as well as my own at times) has harmed our cause and our witness. But God is good. May we discern what part we need to play and how.
Thx!
Which makes it even worse that he got behind her on this.
True enough… this really is a political liability for him with his base… as we can see from the comments in this blog – with a couple who are a part of his constituency.
I had heard the reasons Sen. Brownback was backing Sebelius but I still believe it is wrong for him to back her for any reason.
I agree. It doesn't make sense to me either. Though I'm sure Kansas will be better off without her.