This morning, I posted an essay on the relationship between principles and pragmatism in politics. It was a response to Shane Vander Hart’s article criticizing Mike Huckabee for his support of the House’s actions approving a budget that (at the time) was said to be a true reduction of $38 billion.

I am afraid that by going into such detail about the differences between the two approaches, the application of the philosophy to the case at hand was missed.  I did not think the vote was a matter of principle, no matter whether you disagree with Huckabee on the wisdom of his position.  Challenge his viewpoint, if you will, but I think it is off base to question his character, principles or integrity on this issue.

I did list two exceptions:

1.  If the candidate you support or the congressman has promised to only vote for a budget that reduces the deficit by “X” amount.  (The principle would be “don’t vote different than you promised”).

2. They would never ever vote for a budget that did not totally defund Planned Parenthood (The principle is that the organization must be defunded now, and they won’t budge on anything else until that happens.). 

I offer the challenge for any potential president candidate to say they would veto any budget proposal that did not defund Planned Parenthood.

If none come forward (or their representatives) I will assume that no one believed that this vote was a matter of principle, and therefore all talk that Huckabee has lost the moral highground is unfounded.

2 comments

Comments are closed.

Get CT In Your Inbox!

Don't miss a single update.

You May Also Like

Former California Governor Pete Wilson Endorses Ted Cruz

Former California Governor Pete Wilson “wholeheartedly” endorsed U.S. Senator Ted Cruz (R-TX) at the California Republican State Convention on Saturday.

Mike Huckabee Dings Obama, Clinton on Marriage Hypocrisy

Former Arkansas Governor Mike Huckabee released a web ad slamming President Obama and Hillary Clinton for their complete hypocrisy on same-sex marriage.

Why A High Turnout Is Bad For Democracy

This is going to be one of my most controversial posts so…

How To Prevent Another Trump

John Gustavsson: Apart from certain policy changes, here are a few ideas on how the GOP can ensure that its presidential ticket remains forever clown-free.