santorum-in-paThe Pennsylvania Primary is on April 24th and the release of a new poll by Franklin & Marshall has the chattering class saying Rick Santorum’s lead has vanished in his own state!  He’s losing steamIt disappeared!  The poll which was taken on 3/20 through 3/25 has Santorum with just a two point lead over Mitt Romney – 30% to 28%.  Ron Paul polls third with 9 points and Gingrich is last with 6 points.  There are 24% of voters who are undecided.

The previous Franklin & Marshall poll was done in February.  In it Santorum led the field with 45 points  to Romney’s 16 points.  Gingrich had 9 points to Paul’s 7.  So between February to March according to Franklin & Marshall Santorum’s lead was cut by 27 points.  Santorum lost 15 points, and Romney gained 12.  I find it interesting that the undecided category grew by 2%.  Gingrich lost 3 points… so I would imagine some ended up there.

Here’s what I think is happening, so let’s not get all excited over one poll.

For starters I question whether Santorum ever really lead by 29 points.  That was one poll.  The other poll taken in February which was the first to show a Santorum lead was done by Susquehanna, and he only led by 1 point.  Susquehanna did the previous poll before that in December and Gingrich was up by 17 points.  So you have two polls in the same month which has a 28 point difference in Santorum’s lead.


A little history lesson.  Back in May of 2006 during Santorum’s race with Bob Casey to retain his Senate seat Franklin & Marshall had Casey leading Santorum by five points which was a drop from an 11 point lead from February of 2006.  Rasmussen that same month had Casey leading Santorum by 23 points.

So there’s the question of inaccuracy in the past.  There’s also the question of inaccuracy in the present.  If you were to look at the other two polls done in March, one by Quinnipiac and one by Public Policy Polling you’d see that Santorum has a 14 point and 18 point lead respectively.  Granted both were taken before Romney’s win in the Illinois Primary and Santorum’s win in the Louisiana Primary but it’s doubtful Romney’s win in Illinois would have made that much of an impact.

So what to make of this?  One I think some people who have been pushing Romney as the nominee are getting far too excited about one poll.  Secondly, Franklin & Marshall’s polling accuracy is in question.  Thirdly is it really that surprising to see a race tighten as it gets closer?  Franklin & Marshall point out that Romney leads in the east – that’s his bread & butter – the urban areas.  Those are the parts of the state which are more moderate.  Yes, moderate voters and urban voters are coming home to roost with Romney like they have in every other contest we’ve seen.  He still has a problem with conservatives and evangelicals.

Anyway, I think its far too early to say Romney has a surge going in Pennsylvania based on one poll.

You May Also Like

How to Lose the Iowa Caucus: Jeb Bush Attacks Steve King

Former Gov. Jeb Bush (R-FL) is going to be a long-shot candidate if he decides to run for President in the Iowa Caucus. Attacking Steve King doesn’t help.

Quoting Obama Isn’t Attacking Him

The Obama Campaign launched an ad today, saying Mitt Romney misquoted President…

Tulsi Gabbard Sues Hillary Clinton Over Russia Comments

Tulsi Gabbard filed a defamation lawsuit against Hillary Clinton asking for damages for Clinton claiming Gabbard is a Russian asset.