Photo credit: Gregory Hauenstein
2013 Iowa Democratic Party Jefferson Jackson Dinner (From left) Candidate for Congress in District 3 Staci Appel,
candidate for Congress in District 4 Jim Mowrer,candidate for Secretary of State Brad Anderson and candidate for State Auditor Jon Neiderbach.
Photo credit: Gregory Hausenstein (CC-By-NC-SA 2.0)

Most reasonable people would see the Supreme Court’s Hobby Lobby ruling on the Obama administration’s birth control mandate as protecting basic religious freedom.

A family-owned company or “closely-held” company shouldn’t be mandated by their government to violate their religious conscience by having to pay for an insurance plan that covers abortifacients or birth control in general.

(They shouldn’t be mandated to provide any kind of health insurance, but that’s a whole different subject.)

We are told the privacy of the bedroom is sacrosanct and decisions related to women’s health are also private.

The only problem is that they want others to pay for their private behavior and private decisions.

The Iowa Democratic Party and Iowa 3rd Congressional District candidate Staci Appel don’t see it that way.

But then again, I said reasonable people, and when it comes to issues like this liberals are rarely reasonable.

Iowa Democratic Party spokes person Christina Freundlich said after the ruling, “No woman should have her access to affordable birth control cut off because of her boss’ opinion.”

Appel said in a released statement after the SCOTUS ruling on Monday, “Every Iowan deserves access to high quality health care coverage, regardless of where they work and women’s health care decisions should be made between her and her doctor, not her employer. Today’s decision by the Supreme Court is a blow to Iowa’s working women and I respectfully disagree with the Court’s decision.”

First, access has not been blocked.  Hobby Lobby employees still have health care coverage.  No one is blocking access to birth control that they decide to pay for on their own.

Second if you don’t like the health care coverage your employer offers you are free to change employers.  Be thankful you have health coverage those.

Third, how much of a sense of entitlement to you have to have to complain about a company whose plan still offers coverage for birth control?  Hobby Lobby’s insurance plan covers 16 types of contraceptives.

This is denying access to “high quality health care coverage” or “affordable birth control”?

Here is what Hobby Lobby provides for their female employees (HT Deroy Murdock):

  1. Male condoms
  2. Female condoms
  3. Diaphragms with spermicide
  4. Sponges with spermicide
  5. Cervical caps with spermicide
  6. Spermicide alone
  7. Birth-control pills with estrogen and progestin (“Combined Pill)
  8. Birth-control pills with progestin alone (“The Mini Pill)
  9. Birth control pills (extended/continuous use)
  10. Contraceptive patches
  11. Contraceptive rings
  12. Progestin injections
  13. Implantable rods
  14. Vasectomies
  15. Female sterilization surgeries
  16. Female sterilization implants

Obviously the male condoms or vasectomies is something she would choose in conjunction with her husband.

This is what Hobby Lobby will not provide coverage for what they (and most pro-life folks) believe are abortifacients – contraceptives that instead of simply preventing fertilization kill unborn children while they are fertilized egg.

  1. Plan B (“The Morning After Pill”)
  2. Ella (a similar type of “emergency contraception”)
  3. Copper Intra-Uterine Device
  4. IUD with progestin

Hobby Lobby does not have a policy in place that prevents their employees from using these types of contraceptives.  They just are unwilling to pay for them.  How entitled does one have to be to think providing for 16 different types of contraceptives instead of 20 is blocking access from quality health care?

You May Also Like

An Organization Helping Central Iowans in Need

Jack Whitver: DMARC is devoted to its mission of fighting food insecurity and helping our fellow central Iowans who are in need of food and even personal items including diapers.

Reynolds Appoints Scott Marler to Head the Iowa Department of Transportation

Gov. Kim Reynolds announced the appointment of Scott Marler to serve as Director at the Iowa Department of Transportation

Now is the Time to Create a Better Tax Climate

John Hendrickson: The Iowa Legislature has a unique opportunity to enact tax relief by lowering rates across-the-board and begin the process of controlling spending with the 99 percent spending limitation amendment.

Audio: Joni Ernst Discusses Support for Caregivers During Tele-Town Hall

U.S. Senator Joni Ernst answered questions from Iowans and discussed her COVID-19 relief efforts, including her work to support Iowa’s family caregivers.