ADVERTISEMENT

image Australian Anglican and Old Testament Scholar, Graeme Goldsworthy, wrote in his book, Preaching the Whole Bible as Christian Scripture, that the type of preaching that rejects the gospel enforces legalism and lusts after self-help:

. . . we are all legalists at heart.  We all love to be able to say that we have fulfilled all kinds of conditions, be they tarrying, surrendering fully, or getting rid of every known sin, so that God might truly bless us.  It is a constant temptation to want to take our spiritual pulse and to apply the sanctification barometer. . . . The preacher can aid and abet this legalistic tendency that is at the heart of the sin within us all.  All we have to do is emphasize our humanity: our obedience, our faithfulness, our surrender to God, and so on.  The trouble is that these things are all valid biblical truths, but if we get them out of perspective and ignore their relationship to the gospel of grace, they replace grace with law.

If we constantly tell people what they should do in order to get their lives in order, we place a terrible legalistic burden on them.  Of course they should obey God; of course we should love him with all our heart, mind, soul, and strength.  The Bible tells us so.  But if we ever give the impression that it is possible to do this on our own, not only do we make the gospel irrelevant, but we suggest that the law is in fact a lot weaker in its demands than it really is.  Legalism demeans the law by reducing its standards to the level of our competence.

[ . . .] In practical terms, if we as preachers lay down the marks of the spiritual Christian, or the mature church, or the godly parent, or the obedient child, or the caring pastor, or the responsible elder, or the wise church leader, and if we do this in a way that implies that conformity is simply a matter of understanding and being obedient, then we are being legalists and we risk undoing the very thing we want to build up.  We may achieve the outward semblance of conformity to biblical pattern, but we do it at the expense of the gospel of grace that alone can produce the reality of these desirable goals. To say what we should be or do and not link it with a clear exposition of what God has done about our failure to be or do perfectly as he wills is to reject the grace of God and to lead people to lust after self-help and self-improvement in a way that, to call a spade a spade, is godless, (pg. 118-119).

HT: Provocations & Paintings

Subscribe For Latest Updates

Sign up to receive stimulating conservative Christian commentary in your inbox.

Invalid email address
We promise not to spam you. You can unsubscribe at any time.
You May Also Like

Is Freedom of Religion Fading?

On a cold November morning in 1620, one hundred and one British…

Little Miss Attila Writes About Dressing Modestly

Little Miss Attila, who is no “right-wing fanatic” (unlike me), has a…

Remembering 9/11

It’s hard to believe that it has already been 11 years since…

The Wrong Way to Reach LGBTQ People During Pride Month

Shane Vander Hart: As Christians, we are called to love our neighbors, and that includes our LGBTQ neighbors. We are to love them as ourselves. We should also tell them the truth.