Mike Huckabee considers those who leaked classified documents to Wikileaks traitors and calls for the death penalty for those found guilty of such a crime.

Do you think he’s running for President?  Hmmm… maybe so.

He’s not alone in that assessment as former U.N. Ambassador John Bolton also called for the death penalty.

Former Alaska Governor Sarah Palin and her former running mate Arizona Senator John McCain wonder how did a 22-year-old solider get access to such material and what is the Obama administration doing to neutralize Wikileaks?  Yet Army Private First Class Bradley Manning is the sole suspect at the moment and he faces a court martial and up to 52 years in a military prison.

That doesn’t seem like it’s a suitable punishment to Governor Huckabee?  One of our contributors here, David Shedlock, thinks it was appropriate to do so.  He said making political hay by placing blame on the Obama administration is inappropriate, but calling for the execution of a 22-year-old PFC is, saying “it is a matter of principle, not politics.”

I agree the charges need to be taken seriously.  I think spending 52 years in prison is a pretty serious consequence.  Saying Huckabee isn’t doing this for political posturing is being extremely generous looking at his actual record as Governor in dealing with his state’s criminal justice system.  One has to ask is this an attempt to deflect the heat that could come his way in 2012?

Maybe, maybe not… I’m not going to judge his intent as I can’t read his mind.  A better question that both Huckabee and Bolton should ask is whether or not what PFC Manning did, if found guilty, worthy of the death penalty.  They both cite that he committed treason.   While that certainly is a possibility under the Uniform Code of Military Justice.  It also isn’t a required sentence as a court martial has the latitude to determine another sentence.  Should all classified material be considered the same?

Tell you what, let’s let the court martial do it’s work.  We should be concerned about the supervision that this young man was given and it should be addressed, but I don’t think we need to be as concerned about the sentence provided justice is served and steps are taken to make sure it doesn’t happen again.

4 comments
  1. Just think, this buffoone actually ran for POTUS and even more amazing more than one person voted for him.

    1. I’m more concerned about the “buffoone”who resides in the White House. I’m not questioning Huckabee’s ability to be President. I think he’s more than qualified in comparison. I alaso think he’s extremely intelligent.

      Belittling someone doesn’t make an argument.

  2. Perhaps I did not put it well, but my point remains the same. Criticizing Obama is a political statement. I’m not talking about motive, but the comments themselves. Suggesting a sentence for the traitor is not a political statement, though if we were able to read minds we could say what Huckabee’s motives were. I doubt for one moment that Huckabee was thinking about the clemency at all, but I could be wrong. What I am suggesting is that we avoid the temptation to shoot first and ask questions later. That would include our criticism of Republicans and Democrats.

    Why is the 52 years the traitor might receive plenty severe enough, but the 47 years Huckabee reduced Maurice Clemmons sentence to, not nearly enough, considering he was a man who at the time of the sentencing had never shot at anyone.

    There is no question that Governor Huckabee will have to face serious questions about his commutations, but I think it is largely irrelevant to the case at hand.

    1. If that were the only commutation then perhaps you’d have a point.

      My point is that there are levels of severity.

      From what I understand about this case, the death penalty would be extreme. If he was handing out nuclear codes or outing deep cover operatives I’d be right there with you.

      He didn’t. It’s serious, he should be punished, but it shouldn’t cost him his life. And when there is latitude in the UCMJ for sentencing to demand a death penalty is jumping the gun.

Comments are closed.

Get CT In Your Inbox!

Don't miss a single update.

You May Also Like

What Trump’s Tax Plan Does

President Trump’s tax reform plan simplifies the individual income tax in several ways, but the most significant aspect is the corporate income tax cut.

Obama’s Plea for Civility

I’m not really a fan of the National Prayer Breakfast.  I see…

Ron Paul’s Website Hacked During Birthday Money Bomb

Yesterday was Dr. Ron Paul’s birthday and supporters had organized a birthday…

After Aurora Let’s Not Overreact

There is always a tendency to overreact after a tragedy like what…